[houlianpi]

Requirement

Closes #65

User-visible result

A user states the AutoGenesis outcome once. The canonical Skill now resolves install/client/scope evidence, selects existing platform capabilities, proposes one minimum approved repair, proves the requested readiness level, and resumes the original task without delegating technical choices.

Scope

• Deepen the single canonical autogenesis Skill and authenticated install/readiness references.
• Add one structured readiness/result vocabulary and platform-specific candidate/applicability guidance.
• Add all 19 fixed issue cases within the 26-case Skill decision packet.
• Atomically update Contract manifest, Runtime/CLI/docs pins, and VS Code Skill digest.

Non-goals

• No new Skill, command, MCP tool, Runtime behavior, dependency, platform, publication, or generated-write change.
• No Issue [Security] Bind generated writes to trusted approval and directory handles #51 approval/write work.

Interface changes

Canonical Skill/reference content and immutable Contract identity only. No command, MCP schema, package entrypoint, or extension command change.

Acceptance scenarios

Given an install, repair, prepare, validate, execute, record, or continue request
When uniquely observable project/client/scope/target evidence and existing candidates are evaluated
Then the Agent uses the canonical route, asks at most once for one unchanged protected effect set, proves the exact readiness level, and resumes the preserved task

Verification evidence

Check	Result	Evidence
Targeted tests	Pass	Agent Contract focused: 76 passed, 1 intentionally deselected; Appium credential-safe probes: 3 passed; Appium identity/runtime: 3 passed; CLI: 33 passed
Build/type checks	Pass	freeze_assets.py; sync_skills.py --check; git diff --check; extension tsc --noEmit; all required PR CI checks pass
Clean-environment smoke test	Pass	Built wheel SHA-256 60f9106cdd7b1dd8f4dd9443ceefd270c63fe77c3f4977098b98a60bedb308a8; fresh business project, Python 3.11.8/macOS arm64, MCP 1.23.0 and 1.29.1: 222 passed at each bound
Acceptance scenarios	Partial/pending external gates	Static decision/contracts pass. Native macOS and native Windows final-artifact journeys require separate acceptor evidence before release.

Contract identity: 2.1.0 / 3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c
Canonical Skill SHA-256: 1d1bfffc3e467a4a6cafbbf860740a1ee58f33dad522336779f0da8107464771
Prepared 26-case Skill request set: fe6f2b91e261a2ad61e38b2bb70d31ade0633ef1bca5c829dc2d097de05dad0d. Same-model/harness baseline/candidate traces and independent grading remain required before merge.

Agent roles and review gate

• Implementer: OMP coding agent
• Independent reviewer: Issue65Review (reviewer), Approved after blocking eval coverage fix and final Appium security-contract restoration
• Security coverage: same independent reviewer
• Separate acceptor: required
• Acceptance-gate reason, if required: issue requires clean native macOS and Windows installation/repair/readiness journeys with final built artifacts

Security review

• Secrets and sensitive inputs are not written to logs, generated code, or tracked configuration.
• File writes remain scoped and atomic; no write implementation changed.
• Command/process inputs are fixed or argv-based and not interpolated from untrusted content.
• Package downloads and official Appium guidance remain authenticated/pinned.
• Registry checks emit host/connectivity only; raw URLs, tokens, diagnostics, paths, and device identifiers stay out of durable evidence.

Compatibility impact

Native macOS/Android/iOS routes continue through Appium MCP; native Windows continues through Windows MCP. Contract version remains 2.1.0 with a new manifest digest. Consumer pins and the VS Code Skill digest are updated atomically. Linux/WSL remain unsupported.

Rollback

Revert commit e187985a50f215141c6ce59849ad4e7cf4afd06c and restore the prior Contract manifest plus all consumer pins together. No user data migration is involved.

Known limitations

• Same-model/harness prompt comparison and raw-trace grading are prepared but not yet executed.
• Native macOS and Windows clean-environment journeys remain acceptance gates before release.
• No package or immutable release publication occurs in this PR.

Definition of Done

• The issue met Definition of Ready before implementation began.
• Scope and non-goals were preserved.
• All acceptance scenarios pass in their required environments; native acceptor evidence is pending.
• Required CI checks pass for the prior equivalent tree; checks are rerunning after the base change.
• One independent reviewer approved the change.
• A separate acceptor posted native clean-environment evidence.
• Security coverage passed.
• Prompt changes include a same-model/harness eval comparison; request packets are prepared.
• Documentation and machine-readable configuration agree.

[houlianpi]

Product Owner decision: native Windows acceptance is deferred until a Windows machine is available after this code submission. This is not a pass claim and no substitute evidence will be used. The future Windows acceptor must use the exact submitted artifacts on a clean native interactive Windows host and attach the installation/repair/readiness/Notepad evidence before release. Prompt eval and native macOS acceptance remain active now.

[houlianpi]

Independent native macOS acceptance: Changes Requested — externally blocked.

Final head e187985a50f215141c6ce59849ad4e7cf4afd06c; native macOS 26.7.2 arm64, base CPython 3.11.9, Copilot CLI 1.0.106. Obtained the exact final-head CI Candidate from run 42588758370, artifact 13660117733; independently verified every listed member hash and the wheel-embedded Contract manifest/Skill. No implementer environment, configuration, running service, or business project was reused.

One complete project-install plan (issue65-macos-install-01) was explicitly approved once. Created only a new temporary business project, clean isolated venv (initially pip/setuptools only, no system site packages), and empty task-owned home/client/staging directories. No platform/device/application detour occurred.

Exact blocker: approved hash-locked third-party wheel acquisition could not complete. The first observed failed wheel was annotated_types-0.8.0-py3-none-any.whl. Pip exited 2 with a 15-second files.pythonhosted.org read timeout; retrying only the interrupted download with a 90-second timeout also exited 2. A bounded independent curl HEAD check exited 35 (Socket is not connected), HTTP status 000. Zero wheels were staged. No mirror, substituted bytes, relaxed lock, editable source, or mock was used.

Stopped before the offline package transaction, canonical Skill installation, or MCP entry write. Diagnosis/approved minimum repair, current-Agent initialize/discovery/identity, Target Prepared, real Mac2 Live Ready, visible Calculator 2+3=5, and second-run idempotence are not reached/unproven. The download retry is not an idempotence pass. No Machine Ready or business-success claim is made; no product defect is inferred from this network blocker.

No Runtime/server/session/application was started, so no server/session cleanup is required. User configuration, applications, and privacy controls remain untouched; repository files are unchanged. Sanitized metadata, approval/effect accounting, transcript, installation diagnostics, and artifact inventory are retained locally. Restore approved-source connectivity, then reuse the same Candidate, isolated environment, and unchanged approval to resume at the blocked download. PR readiness and merge state are unchanged.

Exact SHA-256 inventory

Artifact	SHA-256
Candidate manifest	f3c7993eb6606937378fb1ea65776d4c7e7b2fb6fbc8318485b0c1ef5ea9985a
Agent Contract 2.1.0 wheel	2f6ada0d53007d6d9fa62c35e6e0e1c7002a8dcefebf4059d56e7955c74959d0
Appium MCP 0.5.0 wheel	676eae65ee6e22b31736b42375451daad20176a918b065d1e1b834fba43398b4
Windows MCP 0.5.0 wheel (recorded, not installed on macOS)	cd0fa1e78722315ba448eab87a407ea0c1d4d29c4e4fdfc59975544397d5f521
CLI 0.2.0 wheel	a44542b60a5377256d3ca0cdca480641c6e53151f7e72cae86bba2be6ca378b2
Candidate dependency lock	0fc7260ece33e069a061b4bfbd005242881a73600d47212fec7fe6f6b50920f2
Candidate offline-install lock	44d40afcf1f36431251b14e4b1536257ce38527f86f04911237a4c66f41a8f75
Canonical Skill, also verified inside Contract wheel	1d1bfffc3e467a4a6cafbbf860740a1ee58f33dad522336779f0da8107464771
Embedded Contract manifest, version 2.1.0	3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c
Candidate install prompt	3eaf1ce00f2408a84ed9df7b390da4b895da0191318ed3622bc49aa97313e4ab
Candidate SHA256SUMS file	c9b4d5cc7082a5a67234c55c26024c7a2082d2068cf96fb407d6122d1b1eaac7
CI artifact archive (GitHub-reported metadata digest)	8e906fca3225b0fbf795569390b5f6626b8012c19779684ab2a37a939113bcc9

[houlianpi]

Independent native macOS acceptance: Changes Requested — externally blocked.

Final head e187985a50f215141c6ce59849ad4e7cf4afd06c; native macOS 26.7.2 arm64, base CPython 3.11.9, Copilot CLI 1.0.106. Obtained the exact final-head CI Candidate from run 42588758370, artifact 13660117733; independently verified every listed member hash and the wheel-embedded Contract manifest/Skill. No implementer environment, configuration, running service, or business project was reused.

Update after fresh source-only approval: issue65-macos-install-02 supersedes only the third-party source in issue65-macos-install-01. The exact final Candidate, locks, existing clean CPython 3.11.9 venv/business project/client home, Skill scope, MCP effect, persistence, rollback, and verification are unchanged. Two explicit grants cover the initial plan and one source change; no redundant approval request or new environment was introduced. No platform/device/application detour occurred.

Current exact blocker: the approved Microsoft feed is reachable but does not list the locked anthropic==2.6.0 dependency. Retrying only blocked acquisition with the exact dependency lock, hashes required, wheels only, no dependency resolution, and no extra index exited 1: No matching distribution found for anthropic==2.6.0. A bounded read-only inspection of that feed's package index returned HTTP 200 and 467 distribution links, with zero distributions for required 2.6.0. Zero wheels were staged. The source was resolved privately from the configured package-manager setting; no raw registry URL or credential was persisted. First-party AutoGenesis packages were never queried or obtained from the index. The earlier public-source timeouts remain historical evidence, not the current blocker.

Stopped before the offline package transaction, canonical Skill installation, or MCP entry write. Diagnosis/approved minimum repair, current-Agent initialize/discovery/identity, Target Prepared, real Mac2 Live Ready, visible Calculator 2+3=5, and second-run idempotence are not reached/unproven. The download retry is not an idempotence pass. No Machine Ready or business-success claim is made; no product defect is inferred from this network blocker.

No Runtime/server/session/application was started, so no server/session cleanup is required. User MCP configuration, applications, and privacy controls remain untouched; repository files are unchanged. Only the package-source setting was read under explicit approval, with no user configuration writes. Sanitized metadata, approval/effect accounting, transcript, source diagnosis, installation diagnostics, and artifact inventory are retained locally. Make the exact lock-matching anthropic 2.6.0 distribution available through the approved feed, then resume only acquisition using the same Candidate/environment and plan issue65-macos-install-02. No version/hash relaxation or other effect change was made. PR readiness and merge state are unchanged.

Exact SHA-256 inventory

Artifact	SHA-256
Candidate manifest	f3c7993eb6606937378fb1ea65776d4c7e7b2fb6fbc8318485b0c1ef5ea9985a
Agent Contract 2.1.0 wheel	2f6ada0d53007d6d9fa62c35e6e0e1c7002a8dcefebf4059d56e7955c74959d0
Appium MCP 0.5.0 wheel	676eae65ee6e22b31736b42375451daad20176a918b065d1e1b834fba43398b4
Windows MCP 0.5.0 wheel (recorded, not installed on macOS)	cd0fa1e78722315ba448eab87a407ea0c1d4d29c4e4fdfc59975544397d5f521
CLI 0.2.0 wheel	a44542b60a5377256d3ca0cdca480641c6e53151f7e72cae86bba2be6ca378b2
Candidate dependency lock	0fc7260ece33e069a061b4bfbd005242881a73600d47212fec7fe6f6b50920f2
Candidate offline-install lock	44d40afcf1f36431251b14e4b1536257ce38527f86f04911237a4c66f41a8f75
Canonical Skill, also verified inside Contract wheel	1d1bfffc3e467a4a6cafbbf860740a1ee58f33dad522336779f0da8107464771
Embedded Contract manifest, version 2.1.0	3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c
Candidate install prompt	3eaf1ce00f2408a84ed9df7b390da4b895da0191318ed3622bc49aa97313e4ab
Candidate SHA256SUMS file	c9b4d5cc7082a5a67234c55c26024c7a2082d2068cf96fb407d6122d1b1eaac7
CI artifact archive (GitHub-reported metadata digest)	8e906fca3225b0fbf795569390b5f6626b8012c19779684ab2a37a939113bcc9

[houlianpi]

Independent native macOS acceptance: Changes Requested — installation passed; Action Required for isolated-client sign-in.

Final head e187985a50f215141c6ce59849ad4e7cf4afd06c; native macOS 26.7.2 arm64, base CPython 3.11.9, Copilot CLI 1.0.106. Obtained the exact final-head CI Candidate from run 42588758370, artifact 13660117733; independently verified every listed member hash and the wheel-embedded Contract manifest/Skill. No implementer environment, configuration, running service, or business project was reused.

Update under issue65-macos-install-03: the approved Tsinghua TUNA source-only change unblocked acquisition. The exact final Candidate, both locks, existing clean CPython 3.11.9 venv/business project/client home, project scope, MCP effect, persistence, rollback, and verification are unchanged. Three explicit grants cover the initial complete plan and two source-only changes; no redundant approval request or environment recreation occurred. Prior source blockers are historical, not current.

Installation evidence: staged and individually hashed 83 exact locked third-party wheels plus the three verified macOS Candidate wheels. The mirror never resolved or supplied first-party AutoGenesis bytes. One offline package transaction (--require-hashes --force-reinstall --no-index --no-deps) passed, followed by pip check. Installed Contract 2.1.0, Appium MCP 0.5.0, CLI 0.2.0; Windows MCP is not installed on macOS. One canonical autogenesis install --scope project returned installed; Skill SHA-256 matches Candidate bytes. Authenticated install reference returned the expected Contract identity and the internal Appium workflow inventory verified. One previously approved task-owned native MCP entry was added. No platform/device/application/Driver/SDK detour occurred.

Current exact blocker: a real native Copilot discovery attempt in the isolated task client home/business project exited 1 with zero JSON events: No authentication information found. No credentials were extracted, copied, or entered automatically. Shell/writes and built-in MCPs were disabled for that attempt. This attempted isolated native client is explicitly not current parent-session proof, and CLI identity is not MCP identity proof. No Machine Ready claim is made.

Diagnosis-only/no-unauthorized-repair acceptance, current-Agent initialize/prompt/tool/resource/identity proof, Target Prepared, real Mac2 Live Ready, visible Calculator 2+3=5, and second-run idempotence remain unproven/not reached. The initial approved activation is not being relabeled as the separate diagnosis/repair scenario; download retries are not idempotence passes.

One user action: sign in to GitHub Copilot using the task-owned client's native /login UI. The local login-acceptance-client.command launcher selects that isolated client and does not copy credentials. Resume only connection verification afterward, preserving Calculator 2+3=5; do not reinstall or run broad doctor loops.

All commands exited; a scoped process check found zero task-owned Runtimes. No Appium server, Mac2 session, application, or privacy action was started. User MCP configuration, applications, and privacy controls remain untouched; repository files are unchanged. Only the earlier package-source setting was read under explicit approval, with no user configuration writes. Exact artifacts, 86-wheel hash inventory, sanitized transcript, approval/effect accounting, discovery failure, and ownership record are retained. No version/hash relaxation occurred; any further effect change requires fresh approval. PR remains draft; no merge or readiness change was made. This is an incomplete acceptance gate, not an inferred product defect.

Exact SHA-256 inventory

Artifact	SHA-256
Candidate manifest	f3c7993eb6606937378fb1ea65776d4c7e7b2fb6fbc8318485b0c1ef5ea9985a
Agent Contract 2.1.0 wheel	2f6ada0d53007d6d9fa62c35e6e0e1c7002a8dcefebf4059d56e7955c74959d0
Appium MCP 0.5.0 wheel	676eae65ee6e22b31736b42375451daad20176a918b065d1e1b834fba43398b4
Windows MCP 0.5.0 wheel (recorded, not installed on macOS)	cd0fa1e78722315ba448eab87a407ea0c1d4d29c4e4fdfc59975544397d5f521
CLI 0.2.0 wheel	a44542b60a5377256d3ca0cdca480641c6e53151f7e72cae86bba2be6ca378b2
Candidate dependency lock	0fc7260ece33e069a061b4bfbd005242881a73600d47212fec7fe6f6b50920f2
Candidate offline-install lock	44d40afcf1f36431251b14e4b1536257ce38527f86f04911237a4c66f41a8f75
Canonical Skill, also verified inside Contract wheel	1d1bfffc3e467a4a6cafbbf860740a1ee58f33dad522336779f0da8107464771
Embedded Contract manifest, version 2.1.0	3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c
Candidate install prompt	3eaf1ce00f2408a84ed9df7b390da4b895da0191318ed3622bc49aa97313e4ab
Candidate SHA256SUMS file	c9b4d5cc7082a5a67234c55c26024c7a2082d2068cf96fb407d6122d1b1eaac7
CI artifact archive (GitHub-reported metadata digest)	8e906fca3225b0fbf795569390b5f6626b8012c19779684ab2a37a939113bcc9
Complete 86-wheel individual hash inventory	9d8e0947944c8114b2e51db5b0aa7c9dd5574e7033859beb528ca3fa0771404e

[houlianpi]

Independent prompt acceptance: BLOCKED (not passed)

Replacement evaluator; repository read-only. Verified checkout and PR head e187985a50f215141c6ce59849ad4e7cf4afd06c, clean worktree, Contract 2.1.0, and manifest SHA-256 3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c using git rev-parse HEAD, gh pr view 66 --json headRefOid, and shasum -a 256 agent-contract/src/autogenesis_agent_contract/assets/manifest.json.

Read AGENTS.md, governance, issue/PR requirements and discussion, eval README, cases.json, skill_cases.json, _requests.py, evaluate.py, prepare.py, and baseline.json. The fixtures contain 13 Runtime cases per variant and 26 Skill cases.

Exact prerequisite checks and sanitized results:

• python3 --version → Python 3.11.9.
• copilot --version → GitHub Copilot CLI 1.0.106.
• python3 -I -c 'import importlib.metadata as m; print("contract distribution: " + m.version("autogenesis-agent-contract"))' → exit 1, PackageNotFoundError: No package metadata was found for autogenesis-agent-contract.
• python3 agent-contract/evals/prepare.py --output-dir /tmp/autogenesis-issue65-independent-e5a90cb3-requests → exit 1 at the Contract import, ModuleNotFoundError: No module named 'autogenesis_agent_contract'; no request packets produced.

Missing prerequisites: an independently installed built Contract distribution matching the verified identity; an available independent same-exact-model/version execution harness with deterministic mock Runtime, live tool schemas, boundary-timed stimuli/approvals, runtime guards, and raw-transcript/normalized-trace recording. The canonical eval directory supplies packet preparation and trace comparison, not a model-execution runner. No qualifying runner/configuration was supplied in the evaluation instructions or handoff. No implementer runtime/configuration was reused and no credentials were inspected.

Evaluated model/version and execution-harness version: not established; no model requests executed. Evaluator session only: gpt-6.1-sol, Copilot CLI 1.0.106 (not evaluation evidence).

Runtime baseline: 0/13 executed; candidate: 0/13 executed. Skill: 0/26 executed. Pass/fail counts: 0 observed passes, 0 observed failures, all cases unexecuted. Deltas/regressions: unknown, not zero. No traces fabricated and no comparator result claimed.

Stopped promptly at prerequisites, as requested. Prompt acceptance remains unsatisfied. No repository tests, formatting, implementation review, code changes, commits, pushes, PR-state changes, or merge performed.

[houlianpi]

Independent native macOS acceptance: Changes Requested — installation and authenticated connection observed; required native prompt/resource proof blocked.

Final head e187985a50f215141c6ce59849ad4e7cf4afd06c; native macOS 26.7.2 arm64, base CPython 3.11.9, Copilot CLI 1.0.106. Obtained the exact final-head CI Candidate from run 42588758370, artifact 13660117733; independently verified every listed member hash and the wheel-embedded Contract manifest/Skill. No implementer environment, configuration, running service, or business project was reused.

Update under issue65-macos-install-03: the approved Tsinghua TUNA source-only change unblocked acquisition. The exact final Candidate, both locks, existing clean CPython 3.11.9 venv/business project/client home, project scope, MCP effect, persistence, rollback, and verification are unchanged. Three explicit grants cover the initial complete plan and two source-only changes; no redundant approval request or environment recreation occurred. Prior source blockers are historical, not current.

Installation evidence: staged and individually hashed 83 exact locked third-party wheels plus the three verified macOS Candidate wheels. The mirror never resolved or supplied first-party AutoGenesis bytes. One offline package transaction (--require-hashes --force-reinstall --no-index --no-deps) passed, followed by pip check. Installed Contract 2.1.0, Appium MCP 0.5.0, CLI 0.2.0; Windows MCP is not installed on macOS. One canonical autogenesis install --scope project returned installed; Skill SHA-256 matches Candidate bytes. Authenticated install reference returned the expected Contract identity and the internal Appium workflow inventory verified. One previously approved task-owned native MCP entry was added. No platform/device/application/Driver/SDK detour occurred.

Authenticated native connection: user completed isolated /login. Reused the verified installation and plan issue65-macos-install-03; no reinstall, copied credentials, configuration change, or new approval. The real isolated Copilot Agent exited 0. Its native session.mcp_servers_loaded event reports autogenesis-issue65 connected, with serverMetadata.instructions containing the expected Contract 2.1.0 / 3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c. This is actual native initialize-metadata evidence, not package/CLI identity or standalone SDK proof. The Agent reports 31 tool entries and 8 full schemas; no AutoGenesis tool was executed.

Current exact blocker: the tested isolated Agent exposes no native prompt-discovery or resource-list/read interface; commands.changed contains zero commands, and autogenesis://agent-contract/identity could not be read through that Agent. This does not establish that the Runtime has no prompts/resources, and matching initialize metadata is not substituted for the required resource proof. No supported native access route was established from the observed interface and native MCP guidance. The Agent itself reports acceptance incomplete, not Machine Ready. No SDK, new adapter/tool, alternate client, or changed configuration was substituted. Authentication is resolved; no further login is requested.

Per the requested ordering, incomplete prompt/resource connection proof prevents advancing to diagnosis-only/no-unauthorized-repair acceptance, any separately authorized repair, Target Prepared, real Mac2 Live Ready, visible Calculator 2+3=5, or second-run idempotence. These remain unproven/not reached. The initial approved activation is not relabeled as the diagnosis/repair scenario; connection or download retries are not idempotence passes. The Calculator task remains preserved.

All commands exited; final scoped process check found zero task clients/Runtimes. No Appium server, Mac2 session, application, or privacy action was started. User MCP configuration and applications remain untouched; user authentication was completed only by the user. Repository files and the task-owned MCP configuration hash are unchanged. Exact artifacts, all 86 wheel hashes, bounded selected native events, transcript, approval/effect accounting, and ownership record are retained. No further protected effect or version/hash relaxation occurred; a new effect requires fresh approval. PR remains draft, with no merge/readiness change. This verdict records an incomplete client-interface acceptance gate, not an inferred Runtime defect.

Exact SHA-256 inventory

Artifact	SHA-256
Candidate manifest	f3c7993eb6606937378fb1ea65776d4c7e7b2fb6fbc8318485b0c1ef5ea9985a
Agent Contract 2.1.0 wheel	2f6ada0d53007d6d9fa62c35e6e0e1c7002a8dcefebf4059d56e7955c74959d0
Appium MCP 0.5.0 wheel	676eae65ee6e22b31736b42375451daad20176a918b065d1e1b834fba43398b4
Windows MCP 0.5.0 wheel (recorded, not installed on macOS)	cd0fa1e78722315ba448eab87a407ea0c1d4d29c4e4fdfc59975544397d5f521
CLI 0.2.0 wheel	a44542b60a5377256d3ca0cdca480641c6e53151f7e72cae86bba2be6ca378b2
Candidate dependency lock	0fc7260ece33e069a061b4bfbd005242881a73600d47212fec7fe6f6b50920f2
Candidate offline-install lock	44d40afcf1f36431251b14e4b1536257ce38527f86f04911237a4c66f41a8f75
Canonical Skill, also verified inside Contract wheel	1d1bfffc3e467a4a6cafbbf860740a1ee58f33dad522336779f0da8107464771
Embedded Contract manifest, version 2.1.0	3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c
Candidate install prompt	3eaf1ce00f2408a84ed9df7b390da4b895da0191318ed3622bc49aa97313e4ab
Candidate SHA256SUMS file	c9b4d5cc7082a5a67234c55c26024c7a2082d2068cf96fb407d6122d1b1eaac7
CI artifact archive (GitHub-reported metadata digest)	8e906fca3225b0fbf795569390b5f6626b8012c19779684ab2a37a939113bcc9
Complete 86-wheel individual hash inventory	9d8e0947944c8114b2e51db5b0aa7c9dd5574e7033859beb528ca3fa0771404e
Bounded authenticated native Agent discovery evidence	62055ff012f120f0297250dd114fde23423f35d82abc8999bc306e08031a78aa

[houlianpi]

Product Owner support-matrix decision: GitHub Copilot CLI is deferred for this delivery. Its tool-only native MCP surface is retained as evidence but is neither accepted nor a release gate for PR #66. Do not mark the Copilot journey passed and do not add a compatibility adapter to this PR. Native macOS acceptance must be rerun through another explicitly supported client with observable MCP prompt/resource identity and workflow discovery. PR remains Draft until the remaining applicable gates pass.

[houlianpi]

Independent native macOS acceptance: Changes Requested — Codex replacement configured; Action Required for isolated Codex login.

Final head e187985a50f215141c6ce59849ad4e7cf4afd06c; native macOS 26.7.2 arm64, isolated CPython 3.11.9, replacement client Codex CLI 0.166.0. Exact final-head CI Candidate is from run 42588758370, artifact 13660117733; every listed member hash and wheel-embedded Contract manifest/Skill was independently verified. No implementer environment, configuration, running service, or business project was reused.

Product Owner decision and approval: Copilot CLI support is deferred for this delivery; its journey remains compatibility evidence only and is no longer an Issue #65 gate. Fresh plan issue65-macos-codex-01 authorizes installed Codex CLI 0.166.0 and only a new task-owned Codex home/config/MCP entry. Exact Candidate, both locks, existing installed venv, business project, project Skill, 86-wheel inventory and staging from issue65-macos-install-03 are reused unchanged. Four explicit grants cover the initial plan, two source-only changes, and this client replacement; zero redundant approval requests. Full native-interface and macOS acceptance requirements are unchanged.

Installation evidence: staged and individually hashed 83 exact locked third-party wheels plus the three verified macOS Candidate wheels. The mirror never resolved or supplied first-party AutoGenesis bytes. One offline package transaction (--require-hashes --force-reinstall --no-index --no-deps) passed, followed by pip check. Installed Contract 2.1.0, Appium MCP 0.5.0, CLI 0.2.0; Windows MCP is not installed on macOS. One canonical autogenesis install --scope project returned installed; Skill SHA-256 matches Candidate bytes. Authenticated install reference returned the expected Contract identity and the internal Appium workflow inventory verified. One previously approved task-owned native MCP entry was added. No platform/device/application/Driver/SDK detour occurred.

Codex thin preflight: created only the isolated task-owned Codex home/config and one native autogenesis-issue65 entry using the existing Runtime executable and business-project argv. Authentication storage is file-based within that task-owned Codex home. Normal user Codex configuration and credentials were not read or copied. Commands used --no-daemon; no shared app-server daemon was reused. No reinstall, new source, alternate SDK, adapter, or target discovery occurred.

Current exact blocker: native isolated codex login status exits 1, Not logged in. Stopped before Agent/model/discovery calls, as expressly required. Codex initialize metadata, tools/live schemas, prompts discovery/get, and resources list/read of autogenesis://agent-contract/identity are not tested, not classified unsupported. Expected Contract remains 2.1.0 / 3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c.

One user action: complete native Codex device login with HOME, CODEX_HOME and XDG_CACHE_HOME bound to the task-owned acceptance environment. After login, run only the thin actual Codex Agent connection/interface probe; continue diagnosis-only/no-unauthorized-repair, separately approved repair, Target Prepared, real Mac2 Live Ready, visible Calculator 2+3=5, cleanup and second-run idempotence only if full native proof passes. Those later scenarios remain unproven; no approval/acceptance requirement is weakened.

All native Codex setup/status commands exited; no Codex Agent, Runtime, shared daemon, Appium server, Mac2 session, application or privacy action was started by this preflight. Existing artifacts and Copilot compatibility evidence are retained unchanged. User configuration/credentials were not read or copied. Repository files remain unchanged. The new Codex configuration is task-owned only; no protected effect beyond the explicit replacement plan was applied. PR remains Draft, with no merge/readiness change. Verdict is incomplete acceptance pending user login, not a Codex-interface or Runtime-defect finding.

Exact SHA-256 inventory

Artifact	SHA-256
Candidate manifest	f3c7993eb6606937378fb1ea65776d4c7e7b2fb6fbc8318485b0c1ef5ea9985a
Agent Contract 2.1.0 wheel	2f6ada0d53007d6d9fa62c35e6e0e1c7002a8dcefebf4059d56e7955c74959d0
Appium MCP 0.5.0 wheel	676eae65ee6e22b31736b42375451daad20176a918b065d1e1b834fba43398b4
Windows MCP 0.5.0 wheel (recorded, not installed on macOS)	cd0fa1e78722315ba448eab87a407ea0c1d4d29c4e4fdfc59975544397d5f521
CLI 0.2.0 wheel	a44542b60a5377256d3ca0cdca480641c6e53151f7e72cae86bba2be6ca378b2
Candidate dependency lock	0fc7260ece33e069a061b4bfbd005242881a73600d47212fec7fe6f6b50920f2
Candidate offline-install lock	44d40afcf1f36431251b14e4b1536257ce38527f86f04911237a4c66f41a8f75
Canonical Skill, also verified inside Contract wheel	1d1bfffc3e467a4a6cafbbf860740a1ee58f33dad522336779f0da8107464771
Embedded Contract manifest, version 2.1.0	3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c
Candidate install prompt	3eaf1ce00f2408a84ed9df7b390da4b895da0191318ed3622bc49aa97313e4ab
Candidate SHA256SUMS file	c9b4d5cc7082a5a67234c55c26024c7a2082d2068cf96fb407d6122d1b1eaac7
CI artifact archive (GitHub-reported metadata digest)	8e906fca3225b0fbf795569390b5f6626b8012c19779684ab2a37a939113bcc9
Complete 86-wheel individual hash inventory	9d8e0947944c8114b2e51db5b0aa7c9dd5574e7033859beb528ca3fa0771404e
Deferred Copilot native compatibility evidence	62055ff012f120f0297250dd114fde23423f35d82abc8999bc306e08031a78aa
Isolated Codex native preflight evidence	a5ac4491c4e2049cac4f08112ef2fae97fb8c5f22370368d86948b29c8a0dad3
New task-owned Codex configuration	703cfa419ac0bfd6ca942ed3caba0016e2fcc1c33af888d263ebc5e779c22284

[houlianpi]

Independent native macOS acceptance: Changes Requested — current-proxy Codex native probe timed out before completion.

Final head e187985a50f215141c6ce59849ad4e7cf4afd06c; native macOS 26.7.2 arm64, isolated CPython 3.11.9, replacement client Codex CLI 0.166.0. Exact final-head CI Candidate is from run 42588758370, artifact 13660117733; every listed member hash and wheel-embedded Contract manifest/Skill was independently verified. No implementer environment, configuration, running service, or business project was reused.

Product Owner decision and approval: Copilot CLI remains deferred compatibility evidence, not an Issue #65 delivery gate. Plan issue65-macos-codex-02 supersedes only the Codex authentication/model-provider source: use the existing current proxy, no device login. Exact Candidate, both locks, installed venv, business project, Skill, 86-wheel inventory, staging and isolated task MCP configuration are unchanged. Five explicit grants cover the initial installation, two package-source changes, client replacement and provider-source change; no new grant or effect was introduced for this retry.

Installation evidence: staged and individually hashed 83 exact locked third-party wheels plus the three verified macOS Candidate wheels. The mirror never resolved or supplied first-party AutoGenesis bytes. One offline package transaction (--require-hashes --force-reinstall --no-index --no-deps) passed, followed by pip check. Installed Contract 2.1.0, Appium MCP 0.5.0, CLI 0.2.0; Windows MCP is not installed on macOS. One canonical autogenesis install --scope project returned installed; Skill SHA-256 matches Candidate bytes. Authenticated install reference returned the expected Contract identity and the internal Appium workflow inventory verified. One previously approved task-owned native MCP entry was added. No platform/device/application/Driver/SDK detour occurred.

Current-proxy native probe: reused the existing isolated Codex home/MCP file and applied only transient selected current provider/model values. Minimum provider configuration was read privately under approval; no provider URL, token or key was output, persisted or hashed. No normal configuration was modified, credential copied, device login run, package installed, source changed, shared daemon reused, SDK substituted or target discovery requested. Native execution used installed Codex CLI 0.166.0, ephemeral session, read-only sandbox and native JSON output, requesting only initialize/tools/live schemas/prompt/resource/identity proof.

Current exact observation: native Codex exec did not complete within the 240-second bound. No completed native receipt established inference completion or the required interface proof. Inference success is recorded unknown, not asserted failed. This is a probe-completion timeout, not a new DNS, authentication, unsupported-client or Runtime-defect finding. The user's earlier reported DNS failure is historical; their network-resolution update is accepted without requiring reproduction.

Codex initialize metadata, live tool/schema, prompt discovery/get and resource list/read of autogenesis://agent-contract/identity remain unverified, not classified unsupported. Expected Contract stays 2.1.0 / 3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c. With the first ordered gate incomplete, no diagnosis/repair, Target Prepared, real Mac2 Live Ready, visible Calculator 2+3=5 or second-run idempotence pass is claimed. No login action is requested and no substitute was introduced.

The bounded native command ended. Scoped post-probe checks found zero task clients and Runtimes; task MCP configuration SHA-256 is unchanged. No Appium server/application/Mac2 business session or privacy action was requested. Existing artifacts and the original Calculator request are preserved. Normal configuration is unmodified; no secret source data is retained. No further protected effect was applied. PR remains Draft, with no merge/readiness change. Verdict is incomplete native acceptance due to the observed probe timeout, without inferring a product/client conclusion.

Exact SHA-256 inventory

Artifact	SHA-256
Candidate manifest	f3c7993eb6606937378fb1ea65776d4c7e7b2fb6fbc8318485b0c1ef5ea9985a
Agent Contract 2.1.0 wheel	2f6ada0d53007d6d9fa62c35e6e0e1c7002a8dcefebf4059d56e7955c74959d0
Appium MCP 0.5.0 wheel	676eae65ee6e22b31736b42375451daad20176a918b065d1e1b834fba43398b4
Windows MCP 0.5.0 wheel (recorded, not installed on macOS)	cd0fa1e78722315ba448eab87a407ea0c1d4d29c4e4fdfc59975544397d5f521
CLI 0.2.0 wheel	a44542b60a5377256d3ca0cdca480641c6e53151f7e72cae86bba2be6ca378b2
Candidate dependency lock	0fc7260ece33e069a061b4bfbd005242881a73600d47212fec7fe6f6b50920f2
Candidate offline-install lock	44d40afcf1f36431251b14e4b1536257ce38527f86f04911237a4c66f41a8f75
Canonical Skill, also verified inside Contract wheel	1d1bfffc3e467a4a6cafbbf860740a1ee58f33dad522336779f0da8107464771
Embedded Contract manifest, version 2.1.0	3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c
Candidate install prompt	3eaf1ce00f2408a84ed9df7b390da4b895da0191318ed3622bc49aa97313e4ab
Candidate SHA256SUMS file	c9b4d5cc7082a5a67234c55c26024c7a2082d2068cf96fb407d6122d1b1eaac7
CI artifact archive (GitHub-reported metadata digest)	8e906fca3225b0fbf795569390b5f6626b8012c19779684ab2a37a939113bcc9
Complete 86-wheel individual hash inventory	9d8e0947944c8114b2e51db5b0aa7c9dd5574e7033859beb528ca3fa0771404e
Deferred Copilot native compatibility evidence	62055ff012f120f0297250dd114fde23423f35d82abc8999bc306e08031a78aa
Historical isolated Codex login preflight, superseded	a5ac4491c4e2049cac4f08112ef2fae97fb8c5f22370368d86948b29c8a0dad3
New task-owned Codex configuration	703cfa419ac0bfd6ca942ed3caba0016e2fcc1c33af888d263ebc5e779c22284
Sanitized current-proxy Codex native probe receipt	0248629b8a041399c1dd27737ec8f9dbdd4106535832357613591b9f573958f2

[houlianpi]

Independent native macOS acceptance: Changes Requested — MCP-disabled minimal native inference did not complete.

Final head e187985a50f215141c6ce59849ad4e7cf4afd06c; native macOS 26.7.2 arm64, isolated CPython 3.11.9, replacement client Codex CLI 0.166.0. Exact final-head CI Candidate is from run 42588758370, artifact 13660117733; every listed member hash and wheel-embedded Contract manifest/Skill was independently verified. No implementer environment, configuration, running service, or business project was reused.

Product Owner decision and approval: Copilot CLI remains deferred compatibility evidence, not an Issue #65 delivery gate. Plan issue65-macos-codex-02 supersedes only the Codex authentication/model-provider source: use the existing current proxy, no device login. Exact Candidate, both locks, installed venv, business project, Skill, 86-wheel inventory, staging and isolated task MCP configuration are unchanged. Five explicit grants cover the initial installation, two package-source changes, client replacement and provider-source change; no new grant or effect was introduced for this retry.

Installation evidence: staged and individually hashed 83 exact locked third-party wheels plus the three verified macOS Candidate wheels. The mirror never resolved or supplied first-party AutoGenesis bytes. One offline package transaction (--require-hashes --force-reinstall --no-index --no-deps) passed, followed by pip check. Installed Contract 2.1.0, Appium MCP 0.5.0, CLI 0.2.0; Windows MCP is not installed on macOS. One canonical autogenesis install --scope project returned installed; Skill SHA-256 matches Candidate bytes. Authenticated install reference returned the expected Contract identity and the internal Appium workflow inventory verified. One previously approved task-owned native MCP entry was added. No platform/device/application/Driver/SDK detour occurred.

One discriminating sequence under unchanged issue65-macos-codex-02: reused the installed client, exact current proxy/provider/model path, isolated home and existing task MCP file. Native mcp list --json confirmed the sole task server disabled by transient override. No configuration file changed. Minimum provider values were read privately for transient invocation only; no provider URL, token or key was output, persisted or hashed.

Minimal inference result: requested only fixed harmless token AUTOGENESIS_PROBE_OK, with no tools or files. Native thread.started and turn.started appeared at 0.06 seconds, followed by five reconnect/error events; last native error was at 90.28 seconds. No token or completed turn arrived within the 120-second ceiling. The supervisor terminated the task-owned process group with SIGTERM; observed exit -15, elapsed 120.16 seconds. This exit is supervisor termination, not a provider HTTP status.

Discriminated layer: native inference/provider reconnect-error before MCP capability proof, with MCP disabled. The underlying provider/network cause is unverified; no new DNS, authentication, unsupported-interface or Runtime-defect conclusion is drawn. The historical 240-second combined timeout remains ambiguous, but is no longer the sole evidence.

As instructed, the 600-second MCP probe was not attempted, because minimal inference did not pass. No third retry or substitute occurred. Initialize, live schemas, prompt discovery/get, resource list/read and matching identity remain unverified. Expected Contract stays 2.1.0 / 3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c. No diagnosis/repair, Target Prepared, Mac2 Live Ready, visible Calculator 2+3=5 or second-run idempotence pass is claimed.

Scoped post-run checks, excluding the inspection process and its ancestors, found zero task clients and Runtimes. Task MCP configuration and exact installed artifacts are unchanged. No setup, login, credential copy, reinstall, SDK proof, application/session or privacy action occurred. Original Calculator task and task-owned evidence are preserved; normal configuration/applications remain unmodified. Repository is unchanged at the exact final head; PR remains Draft. Verdict records incomplete acceptance, not a proven product defect.

Exact SHA-256 inventory

Artifact	SHA-256
Candidate manifest	f3c7993eb6606937378fb1ea65776d4c7e7b2fb6fbc8318485b0c1ef5ea9985a
Agent Contract 2.1.0 wheel	2f6ada0d53007d6d9fa62c35e6e0e1c7002a8dcefebf4059d56e7955c74959d0
Appium MCP 0.5.0 wheel	676eae65ee6e22b31736b42375451daad20176a918b065d1e1b834fba43398b4
Windows MCP 0.5.0 wheel (recorded, not installed on macOS)	cd0fa1e78722315ba448eab87a407ea0c1d4d29c4e4fdfc59975544397d5f521
CLI 0.2.0 wheel	a44542b60a5377256d3ca0cdca480641c6e53151f7e72cae86bba2be6ca378b2
Candidate dependency lock	0fc7260ece33e069a061b4bfbd005242881a73600d47212fec7fe6f6b50920f2
Candidate offline-install lock	44d40afcf1f36431251b14e4b1536257ce38527f86f04911237a4c66f41a8f75
Canonical Skill, also verified inside Contract wheel	1d1bfffc3e467a4a6cafbbf860740a1ee58f33dad522336779f0da8107464771
Embedded Contract manifest, version 2.1.0	3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c
Candidate install prompt	3eaf1ce00f2408a84ed9df7b390da4b895da0191318ed3622bc49aa97313e4ab
Candidate SHA256SUMS file	c9b4d5cc7082a5a67234c55c26024c7a2082d2068cf96fb407d6122d1b1eaac7
CI artifact archive (GitHub-reported metadata digest)	8e906fca3225b0fbf795569390b5f6626b8012c19779684ab2a37a939113bcc9
Complete 86-wheel individual hash inventory	9d8e0947944c8114b2e51db5b0aa7c9dd5574e7033859beb528ca3fa0771404e
Deferred Copilot native compatibility evidence	62055ff012f120f0297250dd114fde23423f35d82abc8999bc306e08031a78aa
Historical isolated Codex login preflight, superseded	a5ac4491c4e2049cac4f08112ef2fae97fb8c5f22370368d86948b29c8a0dad3
New task-owned Codex configuration	703cfa419ac0bfd6ca942ed3caba0016e2fcc1c33af888d263ebc5e779c22284
Historical combined 240-second native probe receipt	0248629b8a041399c1dd27737ec8f9dbdd4106535832357613591b9f573958f2
MCP-disabled minimal inference discrimination receipt	4371ac18c71c4b828ad09eafd906f211102cbaa180ea72a47404c153f855df14

[houlianpi]

Independent native macOS acceptance: Changes Requested — OMP inference and native resource identity passed; full native proof remains incomplete.

Final head e187985a50f215141c6ce59849ad4e7cf4afd06c; native macOS 26.7.2 arm64, isolated CPython 3.11.9, replacement client OMP 18.0.5. Exact final-head CI Candidate is from run 42588758370, artifact 13660117733; every listed member hash and wheel-embedded Contract manifest/Skill was independently verified. No implementer environment, configuration, running service, or business project was reused.

Approval and isolation: fresh issue65-macos-omp-01 authorizes only new task-owned OMP home/config and one native MCP entry, reusing the exact installation, project, Skill and staging. Six explicit grants total; no redundant installation or approval loop. Normal OMP configuration was neither read nor modified; no credentials were copied, login run, or source secrets output/persisted/hashed. Copilot remains deferred compatibility evidence. Codex remains blocked before MCP at current-proxy inference, without a product/client conclusion.

Installation evidence: staged and individually hashed 83 exact locked third-party wheels plus the three verified macOS Candidate wheels. The mirror never resolved or supplied first-party AutoGenesis bytes. One offline package transaction (--require-hashes --force-reinstall --no-index --no-deps) passed, followed by pip check. Installed Contract 2.1.0, Appium MCP 0.5.0, CLI 0.2.0; Windows MCP is not installed on macOS. One canonical autogenesis install --scope project returned installed; Skill SHA-256 matches Candidate bytes. Authenticated install reference returned the expected Contract identity and the internal Appium workflow inventory verified. One previously approved task-owned native MCP entry was added. No platform/device/application/Driver/SDK detour occurred.

Early OMP inference passed: one bounded native run with no MCP entry, project MCP discovery disabled, no tools/extensions and isolated state returned exactly AUTOGENESIS_PROBE_OK. Exit 0; 10.6 seconds within a 120-second ceiling. Only then was the single documented OMP-native task entry created, using the existing verified Runtime executable and business-project argv.

Actual OMP Agent partial MCP proof: native RPC command discovery advertised three AutoGenesis MCP prompt commands; native resources output listed autogenesis://agent-contract/identity; the native MCP connection test reported connected. The actual Agent's native read tool called that exact identity URI and returned Contract 2.1.0 / 3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c, matching Candidate. No standalone MCP SDK, host tool/URI registration, adapter or alternate client was used.

Exact remaining blocker is evidence collection, not an established missing client capability. Initialize name/version metadata, live MCP schema discovery and a retrieved-prompt receipt remain unverified. The first collection had an acceptor JSON parser TypeError. Subsequent collection did not establish MCP schemas through direct get_state selection; its native tool list includes hub, so this does not prove schemas unavailable. The final prompt-get request was accepted and emitted native prompt_result plus extension_error, but the collector did not retain/handle the local-completion detail and waited for agent_end until its 600-second ceiling (600.17 seconds elapsed, native exit 0). This does not prove a native prompt-get timeout, unsupported OMP interface or Runtime defect.

Stopped without further probes or substitutes. Full native interface proof did not pass, so no Machine Ready, diagnosis/repair, Target Prepared, Mac2 Live Ready, visible Calculator 2+3=5 or second-run idempotence pass is claimed. Original Calculator task remains preserved. Verdict is incomplete acceptance, not a demonstrated implementation defect.

Scoped cleanup checks, excluding the inspection process and ancestors, found zero task clients/Runtimes. New OMP MCP configuration is unchanged after creation; prior client state and installed artifacts are preserved. No reinstall, package-source change, Appium server, Mac2 session, application or privacy action occurred. Repository remains unchanged at the exact final head; PR remains Draft with no readiness/merge change.

Exact SHA-256 inventory

Artifact	SHA-256
Candidate manifest	f3c7993eb6606937378fb1ea65776d4c7e7b2fb6fbc8318485b0c1ef5ea9985a
Agent Contract 2.1.0 wheel	2f6ada0d53007d6d9fa62c35e6e0e1c7002a8dcefebf4059d56e7955c74959d0
Appium MCP 0.5.0 wheel	676eae65ee6e22b31736b42375451daad20176a918b065d1e1b834fba43398b4
Windows MCP 0.5.0 wheel (recorded, not installed on macOS)	cd0fa1e78722315ba448eab87a407ea0c1d4d29c4e4fdfc59975544397d5f521
CLI 0.2.0 wheel	a44542b60a5377256d3ca0cdca480641c6e53151f7e72cae86bba2be6ca378b2
Candidate dependency lock	0fc7260ece33e069a061b4bfbd005242881a73600d47212fec7fe6f6b50920f2
Candidate offline-install lock	44d40afcf1f36431251b14e4b1536257ce38527f86f04911237a4c66f41a8f75
Canonical Skill, also verified inside Contract wheel	1d1bfffc3e467a4a6cafbbf860740a1ee58f33dad522336779f0da8107464771
Embedded Contract manifest, version 2.1.0	3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c
Candidate install prompt	3eaf1ce00f2408a84ed9df7b390da4b895da0191318ed3622bc49aa97313e4ab
Candidate SHA256SUMS file	c9b4d5cc7082a5a67234c55c26024c7a2082d2068cf96fb407d6122d1b1eaac7
CI artifact archive (GitHub-reported metadata digest)	8e906fca3225b0fbf795569390b5f6626b8012c19779684ab2a37a939113bcc9
Complete 86-wheel individual hash inventory	9d8e0947944c8114b2e51db5b0aa7c9dd5574e7033859beb528ca3fa0771404e
Deferred Copilot native compatibility evidence	62055ff012f120f0297250dd114fde23423f35d82abc8999bc306e08031a78aa
Historical isolated Codex login preflight, superseded	a5ac4491c4e2049cac4f08112ef2fae97fb8c5f22370368d86948b29c8a0dad3
New task-owned Codex configuration	703cfa419ac0bfd6ca942ed3caba0016e2fcc1c33af888d263ebc5e779c22284
Historical combined 240-second native probe receipt	0248629b8a041399c1dd27737ec8f9dbdd4106535832357613591b9f573958f2
MCP-disabled minimal inference discrimination receipt	4371ac18c71c4b828ad09eafd906f211102cbaa180ea72a47404c153f855df14
New task-owned OMP native MCP configuration	6fbc8300d997f9ff9ac416ac2eea8490a59f54e1d10f27cb76097f130aca2667
OMP approval effect set	d19f703be67d25f2a4b928a1426db35a2ba4968ec6730cbd1df95ebb4cf61d32
OMP partial native proof and explicit collector limitations	d598ddc6e9054129dd6f6e843f32eed20ad4507026825212932a6569ba5eb129

[houlianpi]

Independent native macOS acceptance: Changes Requested — supplemental local completion handling corrected; full native proof remains incomplete.

Final head e187985a50f215141c6ce59849ad4e7cf4afd06c; native macOS 26.7.2 arm64, isolated CPython 3.11.9, replacement client OMP 18.0.5. Exact final-head CI Candidate is from run 42588758370, artifact 13660117733; every listed member hash and wheel-embedded Contract manifest/Skill was independently verified. No implementer environment, configuration, running service, or business project was reused.

Approval and isolation: fresh issue65-macos-omp-01 authorizes only new task-owned OMP home/config and one native MCP entry, reusing the exact installation, project, Skill and staging. Six explicit grants total; no redundant installation or approval loop. Normal OMP configuration was neither read nor modified; no credentials were copied, login run, or source secrets output/persisted/hashed. Copilot remains deferred compatibility evidence. Codex remains blocked before MCP at current-proxy inference, without a product/client conclusion.

Installation evidence: staged and individually hashed 83 exact locked third-party wheels plus the three verified macOS Candidate wheels. The mirror never resolved or supplied first-party AutoGenesis bytes. One offline package transaction (--require-hashes --force-reinstall --no-index --no-deps) passed, followed by pip check. Installed Contract 2.1.0, Appium MCP 0.5.0, CLI 0.2.0; Windows MCP is not installed on macOS. One canonical autogenesis install --scope project returned installed; Skill SHA-256 matches Candidate bytes. Authenticated install reference returned the expected Contract identity and the internal Appium workflow inventory verified. One previously approved task-owned native MCP entry was added. No platform/device/application/Driver/SDK detour occurred.

Reused OMP inference proof, not rerun: the earlier bounded native run with no MCP entry, project MCP discovery disabled, no tools/extensions and isolated state returned exactly AUTOGENESIS_PROBE_OK. Exit 0; 10.6 seconds within a 120-second ceiling. Only then was the single documented OMP-native task entry created, using the existing verified Runtime executable and business-project argv. Its configuration is unchanged.

Reused actual OMP Agent partial proof: native discovery advertised three AutoGenesis MCP prompt commands; resources listed autogenesis://agent-contract/identity; native connection test reported connected. Actual Agent native read of that URI returned Contract 2.1.0 / 3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c, matching Candidate. The prior receipt is unchanged; neither identity nor minimal inference was unnecessarily repeated.

One targeted supplemental collection under unchanged issue65-macos-omp-01: native exit 0, elapsed 55.1 seconds, within a 600-second ceiling. MCP prompt-get reached correlated native prompt_result at 55.02 seconds, correctly treated as terminal local completion without waiting for agent_end. Selected workflow: autogenesis-issue65:execute_natural_language_task. Argument-name receipt is empty; expanded-user-content is false. Separate sanitized error category: native-extension-operation-error. No full prompt/task content or raw error was retained. Local completion is proven, successful prompt retrieval is not.

Exact remaining proof gaps: initialize name/version and capability counts were not extracted from native /mcp list/test output. The Agent's metadata-only turn completed but emitted zero native hub/schema-inspection calls, so no live advertised-tool/schema receipt was established for action, verification or generation tools. No get_state.dumpTools, source files, wheels, SDK or different client was used as a substitute. These are incomplete collector/Agent-routing receipts, not proof that OMP lacks a native schema route or that the connection failed; prior connected evidence remains valid.

Stopped after that single requested supplemental collection, without further probes. Full native proof did not pass, so no Machine Ready, diagnosis/repair, Target Prepared, Mac2 Live Ready, visible Calculator 2+3=5 or second-run idempotence pass is claimed. Original Calculator task remains preserved. Verdict is incomplete acceptance, not an established client/product defect.

Scoped cleanup checks, excluding the inspection process and ancestors, found zero task clients/Runtimes. New OMP MCP configuration is unchanged after creation; prior client state and installed artifacts are preserved. No reinstall, package-source change, Appium server, Mac2 session, application or privacy action occurred. Repository remains unchanged at the exact final head; PR remains Draft with no readiness/merge change.

Exact SHA-256 inventory

Artifact	SHA-256
Candidate manifest	f3c7993eb6606937378fb1ea65776d4c7e7b2fb6fbc8318485b0c1ef5ea9985a
Agent Contract 2.1.0 wheel	2f6ada0d53007d6d9fa62c35e6e0e1c7002a8dcefebf4059d56e7955c74959d0
Appium MCP 0.5.0 wheel	676eae65ee6e22b31736b42375451daad20176a918b065d1e1b834fba43398b4
Windows MCP 0.5.0 wheel (recorded, not installed on macOS)	cd0fa1e78722315ba448eab87a407ea0c1d4d29c4e4fdfc59975544397d5f521
CLI 0.2.0 wheel	a44542b60a5377256d3ca0cdca480641c6e53151f7e72cae86bba2be6ca378b2
Candidate dependency lock	0fc7260ece33e069a061b4bfbd005242881a73600d47212fec7fe6f6b50920f2
Candidate offline-install lock	44d40afcf1f36431251b14e4b1536257ce38527f86f04911237a4c66f41a8f75
Canonical Skill, also verified inside Contract wheel	1d1bfffc3e467a4a6cafbbf860740a1ee58f33dad522336779f0da8107464771
Embedded Contract manifest, version 2.1.0	3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c
Candidate install prompt	3eaf1ce00f2408a84ed9df7b390da4b895da0191318ed3622bc49aa97313e4ab
Candidate SHA256SUMS file	c9b4d5cc7082a5a67234c55c26024c7a2082d2068cf96fb407d6122d1b1eaac7
CI artifact archive (GitHub-reported metadata digest)	8e906fca3225b0fbf795569390b5f6626b8012c19779684ab2a37a939113bcc9
Complete 86-wheel individual hash inventory	9d8e0947944c8114b2e51db5b0aa7c9dd5574e7033859beb528ca3fa0771404e
Deferred Copilot native compatibility evidence	62055ff012f120f0297250dd114fde23423f35d82abc8999bc306e08031a78aa
Historical isolated Codex login preflight, superseded	a5ac4491c4e2049cac4f08112ef2fae97fb8c5f22370368d86948b29c8a0dad3
New task-owned Codex configuration	703cfa419ac0bfd6ca942ed3caba0016e2fcc1c33af888d263ebc5e779c22284
Historical combined 240-second native probe receipt	0248629b8a041399c1dd27737ec8f9dbdd4106535832357613591b9f573958f2
MCP-disabled minimal inference discrimination receipt	4371ac18c71c4b828ad09eafd906f211102cbaa180ea72a47404c153f855df14
New task-owned OMP native MCP configuration	6fbc8300d997f9ff9ac416ac2eea8490a59f54e1d10f27cb76097f130aca2667
OMP approval effect set	d19f703be67d25f2a4b928a1426db35a2ba4968ec6730cbd1df95ebb4cf61d32
OMP partial native proof and explicit collector limitations	d598ddc6e9054129dd6f6e843f32eed20ad4507026825212932a6569ba5eb129
Single targeted OMP supplement: local completion and remaining proof gaps	68eb6ee814c4e6c77778be2bec3c251f770300fbf6c0bfd085a5913c4632a0f0

[houlianpi]

Independent native macOS acceptance: Changes Requested — final RPC v2 collection confirms 31 connected tools; required native proof remains incomplete.

Final head e187985a50f215141c6ce59849ad4e7cf4afd06c; native macOS 26.7.2 arm64, isolated CPython 3.11.9, replacement client OMP 18.0.5. Exact final-head CI Candidate is from run 42588758370, artifact 13660117733; every listed member hash and wheel-embedded Contract manifest/Skill was independently verified. No implementer environment, configuration, running service, or business project was reused.

Approval and isolation: fresh issue65-macos-omp-01 authorizes only new task-owned OMP home/config and one native MCP entry, reusing the exact installation, project, Skill and staging. Six explicit grants total; no redundant installation or approval loop. Normal OMP configuration was neither read nor modified; no credentials were copied, login run, or source secrets output/persisted/hashed. Copilot remains deferred compatibility evidence. Codex remains blocked before MCP at current-proxy inference, without a product/client conclusion.

Installation evidence: staged and individually hashed 83 exact locked third-party wheels plus the three verified macOS Candidate wheels. The mirror never resolved or supplied first-party AutoGenesis bytes. One offline package transaction (--require-hashes --force-reinstall --no-index --no-deps) passed, followed by pip check. Installed Contract 2.1.0, Appium MCP 0.5.0, CLI 0.2.0; Windows MCP is not installed on macOS. One canonical autogenesis install --scope project returned installed; Skill SHA-256 matches Candidate bytes. Authenticated install reference returned the expected Contract identity and the internal Appium workflow inventory verified. One previously approved task-owned native MCP entry was added. No platform/device/application/Driver/SDK detour occurred.

Reused OMP inference proof, not rerun: the earlier bounded native run with no MCP entry, project MCP discovery disabled, no tools/extensions and isolated state returned exactly AUTOGENESIS_PROBE_OK. Exit 0; 10.6 seconds within a 120-second ceiling. Only then was the single documented OMP-native task entry created, using the existing verified Runtime executable and business-project argv. Its configuration is unchanged.

Reused actual OMP Agent partial proof: native discovery advertised three AutoGenesis MCP prompt commands; resources listed autogenesis://agent-contract/identity; native connection test reported connected. Actual Agent native read of that URI returned Contract 2.1.0 / 3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c, matching Candidate. The prior receipt is unchanged; neither identity nor minimal inference was unnecessarily repeated.

Final targeted collection under unchanged issue65-macos-omp-01: fresh native OMP RPC session negotiated protocol v2, with ID-correlated requests and v2 chunk handling. /mcp reload, /mcp list, /mcp test autogenesis-issue65, /mcp resources and /mcp prompts each reached same-ID data.agentInvoked:false completion, followed by output draining. Native exit 0, elapsed 25.88 seconds within a 600-second ceiling. No minimal inference or identity reread.

Completed native command evidence: list reports the task entry enabled. Test output states Server "autogenesis-issue65" connected (31 tools). The connection alias, connected state and tool count were parsed from that retained completed output offline, without another native run. Resources list the exact identity URI; prompts list the three official workflows. This does not establish initialize serverInfo name/version, and a count is not schema proof.

Exact remaining gaps: after completed reload, 40 bounded get_state polls exposed no documented dynamic mcp__<sanitized-server>_<tool> names or parameter schemas; representative action/verification/generation schemas are unproved by this RPC route. Structured get_available_commands input hint was the generic label arguments. The collector incorrectly treated that label as a canonical argument name; that invocation is not established valid. It ended through same-ID prompt_result with sanitized native-extension-operation-error, and no expanded canonical user-message receipt. No full prompt/task content was retained. Successful prompt retrieval and full native proof remain unverified.

The collection observed zero Agent turns and zero tool calls; the immediate-abort safeguard was not triggered. No AutoGenesis business tool executed. Stopped after this explicitly final collection, no further collector retries. No SDK/source/wheel/different-client substitute. No Machine Ready, diagnosis/repair, Target Prepared, Mac2 Live Ready, visible Calculator 2+3=5 or second-run idempotence pass is claimed. This records native RPC exposure gaps and a collector argument-interpretation error, not a blanket OMP/product-defect finding.

Scoped cleanup checks, excluding the inspection process and ancestors, found zero task clients/Runtimes. New OMP MCP configuration is unchanged after creation; prior client state and installed artifacts are preserved. No reinstall, package-source change, Appium server, Mac2 session, application or privacy action occurred. Repository remains unchanged at the exact final head; PR remains Draft with no readiness/merge change.

Exact SHA-256 inventory

Artifact	SHA-256
Candidate manifest	f3c7993eb6606937378fb1ea65776d4c7e7b2fb6fbc8318485b0c1ef5ea9985a
Agent Contract 2.1.0 wheel	2f6ada0d53007d6d9fa62c35e6e0e1c7002a8dcefebf4059d56e7955c74959d0
Appium MCP 0.5.0 wheel	676eae65ee6e22b31736b42375451daad20176a918b065d1e1b834fba43398b4
Windows MCP 0.5.0 wheel (recorded, not installed on macOS)	cd0fa1e78722315ba448eab87a407ea0c1d4d29c4e4fdfc59975544397d5f521
CLI 0.2.0 wheel	a44542b60a5377256d3ca0cdca480641c6e53151f7e72cae86bba2be6ca378b2
Candidate dependency lock	0fc7260ece33e069a061b4bfbd005242881a73600d47212fec7fe6f6b50920f2
Candidate offline-install lock	44d40afcf1f36431251b14e4b1536257ce38527f86f04911237a4c66f41a8f75
Canonical Skill, also verified inside Contract wheel	1d1bfffc3e467a4a6cafbbf860740a1ee58f33dad522336779f0da8107464771
Embedded Contract manifest, version 2.1.0	3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c
Candidate install prompt	3eaf1ce00f2408a84ed9df7b390da4b895da0191318ed3622bc49aa97313e4ab
Candidate SHA256SUMS file	c9b4d5cc7082a5a67234c55c26024c7a2082d2068cf96fb407d6122d1b1eaac7
CI artifact archive (GitHub-reported metadata digest)	8e906fca3225b0fbf795569390b5f6626b8012c19779684ab2a37a939113bcc9
Complete 86-wheel individual hash inventory	9d8e0947944c8114b2e51db5b0aa7c9dd5574e7033859beb528ca3fa0771404e
Deferred Copilot native compatibility evidence	62055ff012f120f0297250dd114fde23423f35d82abc8999bc306e08031a78aa
Historical isolated Codex login preflight, superseded	a5ac4491c4e2049cac4f08112ef2fae97fb8c5f22370368d86948b29c8a0dad3
New task-owned Codex configuration	703cfa419ac0bfd6ca942ed3caba0016e2fcc1c33af888d263ebc5e779c22284
Historical combined 240-second native probe receipt	0248629b8a041399c1dd27737ec8f9dbdd4106535832357613591b9f573958f2
MCP-disabled minimal inference discrimination receipt	4371ac18c71c4b828ad09eafd906f211102cbaa180ea72a47404c153f855df14
New task-owned OMP native MCP configuration	6fbc8300d997f9ff9ac416ac2eea8490a59f54e1d10f27cb76097f130aca2667
OMP approval effect set	d19f703be67d25f2a4b928a1426db35a2ba4968ec6730cbd1df95ebb4cf61d32
OMP partial native proof and explicit collector limitations	d598ddc6e9054129dd6f6e843f32eed20ad4507026825212932a6569ba5eb129
Earlier targeted OMP supplement	68eb6ee814c4e6c77778be2bec3c251f770300fbf6c0bfd085a5913c4632a0f0
Final OMP RPC v2 receipt: completed commands and explicit proof gaps	e714374d0acf703d1b266ae99cacc2660f05d826c47736332369f105fdaa410a

[houlianpi]

Product Owner sequencing decision: pause native macOS business acceptance for PR #66 and address OMP compatibility in #21 before resuming. No client roulette and no acceptance weakening. Reuse the existing final Candidate, clean installation, isolated project, OMP inference/connection/prompt-list/resource-identity evidence, and preserved Calculator task after #21 proves initialize serverInfo, live dynamic schemas, and successful prompt-get through the actual Agent. This PR remains Draft; no readiness or merge change.

[houlianpi]

Native macOS Calculator smoke: Action Required — not executed.

At 2026-11-09 15:08:41 UTC, the isolated OMP acceptor confirmed one pre-existing Calculator process owned by the current desktop user. Per the approved stop condition it preserved that process: no UI read, no input, no close, and no display/history change.

Preflight evidence:

• approved Runtime command/args and task-owned OMP MCP configuration hash matched;
• Xcode 27.2, build 27B52;
• Appium/MCP processes started: 0;
• Mac2 sessions created: 0;
• observed calculation result: none; no pass/failure claim;
• final task-owned client/Runtime process count: 0 at 2026-11-09 15:09:47 UTC;
• repository, GitHub source state, user configuration and privacy permissions unchanged.

Required user action: close the existing Calculator instance when safe, preserving anything needed. Then rerun only the already-approved Appium/Mac2 → Calculator 2+3=5 smoke; no reinstall, identity re-proof, repair or expanded application access.

[houlianpi]

Native macOS smoke resumed after the user closed Calculator: Action Required — Mac2 missing in task-owned Appium scope.

At 2026-11-09 15:14:43 UTC, the selected isolated environment passed Node/npm/Appium/Xcode preflight, then native appium driver list --installed --json exited 0 with {}. This proves only that the task-owned Appium environment has no installed Driver; it does not claim host-wide absence.

Observed versions: Node 26.12.1, npm 11.20.0, Appium 3.7.0, OMP 18.0.5, Xcode 27.2; Xcode first-launch check passed. Per the approved no-repair boundary, the acceptor stopped before installing Mac2, starting Appium/MCP, creating a session, or interacting with Calculator. Result 5 remains unobserved. Calculator display/history was not inspected or changed. Final task process count was 0 at 15:15:27 UTC.

A separate explicit Mac2 installation plan/source/version/scope approval is required before resuming. No installation, user configuration, privacy permission, repository or GitHub source change occurred.

[houlianpi]

Product Owner approved protected-effect plan issue21-macos-mac2-01 to unblock the already-authorized Calculator smoke.

Authorized effect: in the existing task-owned environment only, run appium driver install mac2@4.5.1 --json with HOME bound to /tmp/autogenesis-issue65-macos-acceptance/task/omp-home. This may write only task-owned .appium and npm state and run package lifecycle scripts. No sudo, global Appium mutation, user HOME/config copy, OMP/AutoGenesis reinstall or source change.

Candidate metadata checked before approval: appium-mac2-driver 4.5.1; registry integrity sha512-tlvVAIMNzDsx1KFRgACg2X6Xx72D0ISyLVNNKhHP89k5yIzwA7AcnNokcYbEhFdGSmwyjJLVaHjNPod8sZi5sw==; current public Microsoft npm feed; peer Appium ^3.0.0-rc.2; engines Node ^20.19 || ^22.12 || >=24, npm >=10; current Node 26.12.1, npm 11.20.0, Appium 3.7.0 satisfy them.

After install: verify exact installed inventory, run appium driver doctor mac2, require zero required fixes. If doctor, privacy permission, server smoke or session prerequisite fails, stop before repair and request a new effect. If Ready, continue exactly one Mac2 Calculator 2+3=5 session and cleanup. Rollback is appium driver uninstall mac2 under the same task HOME; do not apply rollback unless requested or needed after failed installation.

[houlianpi]

Plan issue21-macos-mac2-01: installation passed; Runtime target configuration now Action Required.

Official mac2@4.5.1 installed at 2026-11-09 15:21:18 UTC in the approved task-owned HOME. Registry, installed-lock and cached-tarball SHA-512 match the approved integrity. Exact installed inventory contains only mac2@4.5.1. appium driver doctor mac2 reports 0 required fixes; its one optional Full Disk Access warning concerns native video retrieval, which this smoke does not use.

The unchanged OMP MCP command still omits --platform mac, so AutoGenesis Runtime selects its default ios profile. The packaged fallback Mac profile also has empty bundleId. Retargeting exceeds the approved .appium/npm write scope, so the acceptor stopped before Appium/MCP start or session creation. Calculator was not touched and result 5 remains unobserved. Final task process count: 0 at 15:24:15 UTC. Successful Mac2 installation is retained.

Read-only Interface verification: Runtime supports --platform mac and --config <explicit-json>; ConfigManager accepts a task-owned config containing a mac profile; the installed Calculator bundle ID is com.apple.calculator. A separate approval is required to create that task-owned profile and atomically update only the task-owned OMP MCP entry/args, with rollback to the current config bytes.

[houlianpi]

Product Owner approved protected-effect plan issue21-macos-config-01.

Authorized writes are limited to task-owned acceptance state: create one explicit JSON Mac profile outside the business project/repository, with existing Runtime conventions platformName: Mac, automationName: Mac2, verified bundleId: com.apple.calculator, reset disabled, existing timeout/quiescence defaults, and server_url: http://127.0.0.1:4723; atomically update only /tmp/autogenesis-issue65-macos-acceptance/task/omp/mcp.json args to add --platform mac --config <absolute-task-profile> while preserving the approved executable and project root. Record exact before/after bytes and SHA-256; validate JSON and task-root scope before replacement; restore original bytes on write/validation/reload failure.

No business-project, user HOME/config, privacy, repository, package, OMP/Runtime version or shared state change is authorized. After OMP native reload and matching config evidence, start only task-owned loopback Appium/MCP processes, create exactly one Mac2 Calculator session, perform visible 2+3, observe 5, then close session/processes. Any permission, port, server, launch or session prerequisite failure requires stop-before-repair and a new decision.

[houlianpi]

Plan issue21-macos-config-01: stopped before writes due to external OMP version drift.

The native launcher now reports OMP 18.18.3; the previously qualified/approved 18.0.5 location is unavailable. The acceptor did not upgrade OMP. Because the compensating initialize-identity exception and existing client receipts were explicitly version-scoped, they were not transferred silently.

No profile creation, MCP config update or reload occurred. Exact original task-owned OMP MCP bytes were backed up and remain unchanged; before/after SHA-256 6fbc8300d997f9ff9ac416ac2eea8490a59f54e1d10f27cb76097f130aca2667. Appium/MCP starts: 0; sessions: 0; Calculator untouched; result unobserved. Final task process count 0 at 2026-11-09 15:28:36 UTC. Mac2 4.5.1 installation remains retained; repository/GitHub source unchanged.

Required Product Owner decision: either restore exact OMP 18.0.5 or explicitly change the qualification baseline to 18.18.3 and rerun the minimum client compatibility receipts before applying the already-approved task-owned Mac configuration.

[houlianpi]

Product Owner changed the native OMP qualification baseline to current stable 18.18.3; plan issue21-omp-18.18.3-01 supersedes only the client version baseline. Do not reuse 18.0.5 compatibility conclusions as passes.

Ordered thin requalification, before any Mac profile/client write: record exact native binary/version; isolated fixed-token inference with MCP disabled; current task server connected; 31 live schemas using the existing task-only flat-exposure setting; successful canonical prompt-get using actual metadata arguments; actual native resource read matching Contract 2.1.0 / 3768d673273fc82609a94a218a355622233e10892a9f2392688711aa4572d32c. No business tool, Appium server, Mac2 session or Calculator interaction during these gates. Any failed gate stops without substitution.

Only if all compensating receipts pass, the accepted initialize-serverInfo observability exception is extended specifically to OMP 18.18.3. Then apply the already-approved issue21-macos-config-01 task-owned profile/MCP-args change and continue the already-approved single Mac2 Calculator 2+3=5 smoke. Existing Mac2 4.5.1 installation remains valid. No OMP downgrade, package reinstall, user config/privacy change, repository edit, commit, push or merge is authorized.

[houlianpi]

Calculator smoke: task-only approval-controller correction blocked by independent security review; no launch occurred.

OMP 18.18.3 gates 4 and 5 passed before this boundary: canonical prompt expansion 4,992 bytes with abort acknowledged and zero tools; actual native resource read matched Contract 2.1.0 and required manifest. The documented initialize-serverInfo exception is now compensated specifically for OMP 18.18.3. Native Mac config reload/effective config, Appium 3.7.0, Mac2 4.5.1 and loopback readiness also passed.

The first controller revision was not executed. Independent review found:

1. High confidence/high severity: after policy failure/abort is latched, queued in-phase requests can remain approval-eligible while awaiting acknowledgment, violating failure-stop/no-retry.
2. High confidence/medium severity: the one-launch reservation file and replacement do not fsync the containing directory, so a system crash can lose the marker preventing another launch grant.

Stopped per plan before further repair. Live approvals 0; MCP launch dispatches 0; Mac2 sessions 0; Calculator untouched; authorized launch remains unconsumed. Cleanup verified zero task processes and closed ports 4723/10100 at 2026-11-09 16:03:30 UTC. Repository, GitHub source, user config/privacy and accepted task Mac configuration unchanged.

A fresh Product Owner decision is required to repair both task-only harness findings, rerun independent security review, and only then consume the already-approved single launch.

[houlianpi]

Product Owner approved task-only harness plan issue21-controller-fix-02.

Authorized changes are limited to /tmp acceptance-controller artifacts: make approval eligibility fail closed immediately after any policy failure or pending abort; separate the immutable one-launch reservation from mutable response status; durably commit reservation and every atomic replacement by fsyncing the file and containing directory. Preserve the one-launch cap and reject any approval when reservation state is missing, ambiguous or stale.

Required order: deterministic event-order simulations including queued-after-failure; crash-point/restart simulations around reservation create/replace/response; focused independent security review of exact before/after controller artifacts. Only if every check and review passes may the controller consume the existing unspent approval for one native Calculator launch. Any finding stops without another repair. No product/repository/user config change, commit, push or GitHub mutation by the acceptor.

[houlianpi]

Native macOS Calculator smoke remains Blocked: stop after two task-controller security-review iterations.

Plan issue21-controller-fix-02 addressed the original post-failure approval and reservation durability findings. Deterministic validation passed 12 event-order cases, 11 invalid/stale-state cases and 26 crash/restart checkpoints. Fresh independent review nevertheless found one remaining medium-severity/high-confidence path: a business-turn timeout raises before fail_closed() latches failure; cleanup then calls state/drain while task-phase approval eligibility can remain active, so a queued business approval could be granted after timeout.

Per the explicit stop condition and no-repeat-method rule, no third one-off repair is attempted. This now requires a separately designed, independently reviewed acceptance harness rather than another temporary controller patch.

No real approval, MCP launch dispatch or Mac2 session occurred across either revision; the authorized launch remains unspent. Calculator was untouched. Zero task processes and closed ports 4723/10100 were verified at 2026-11-09 16:14:39 UTC. Configuration, repository, GitHub source and user privacy/config remain unchanged from the accepted task-owned Mac configuration.

Preserved passed evidence: OMP 18.18.3 fixed-token inference; connected task MCP; 31 live schemas; native TUI prompt argument metadata; canonical prompt expansion 4,992 bytes with zero tools; actual matching Contract resource identity; compensated serverInfo exception for 18.18.3; task Mac profile/native reload; Appium 3.7.0; Mac2 4.5.1 with zero required doctor fixes; loopback readiness. Calculator 2+3=5 remains unexecuted/unproved.